11 Best Lititz Restaurants

May 10, 2021

We've put together a collection of the 11 Best Lititz Restaurants that you should try while you explore Lancaster County.

Bulls Head Pub Amish Country has a lot to offer, especially the irresistible home cooking of Lititz restaurants. Experience the surroundings of Lancaster, PA in a unique way with this selection of the best local places. Get a taste of the enthralling history of the region and explore the picturesque countryside, as well as the quaint town shops and sites (you've heard that Lititz was voted "Coolest Small Town in America, right?!). Perfect for a solo traveler, a couple’s getaway, or a family adventure, these Lititz restaurants provide great food in a warm atmosphere!

If you like these Lititz restaurants, you will love all the other great places to eat near the Historic Smithton Inn! Visit our Local Activities page to find out about top outdoor activities, fun bars, and more. Start planning your visit today and get ready for some fun!

A Delicious Selection of the 9 Best Lititz Restaurants

Here are 11 of the bests restaurants in Lititz you should absolutely try during your stay.

Tomato Pie Cafe | 23 N Broad St, Lititz

Tomato Pie Cafe is the perfect place for a cozy breakfast or lunch. Sit back and enjoy a cup of rich coffee at the full espresso bar, or enjoy a refreshing latte or loose-leaf tea. You can even accompany your beverage with the restaurant’s famous tomato pie or a bleu cheese and pear salad. Hot sandwiches include ham & brie, turkey & pesto, and chicken panini. This local cafe is the perfect place to regain energy in between your Lancaster, PA, adventures!

Bulls Head Public House | 14 E Main St, Lititz

The Bulls Head Public House is an authentic British pub offering a tasty experience. The wooden decor gives the place an intimate feeling and recreates the atmosphere of old European bars. Plus, the menu has a wide selection of beers, making Bulls Head the best beer bar in Pennsylvania. Our personal favorite is the Young Chocolate Stout. Its unique flavor is something you do not want to miss! If you’re hungry, enjoy a delicious English eggs and sausage plate in a warm and friendly setting.

[Related: Craft Breweries in Lancaster PA]

Lititz Family Cupboard Restaurant & Buffet | 12 W Newport Rd, Lititz

The Lititz Family Cupboard Restaurant & Buffet is another great place to get a taste of Pennsylvania’s favorites. Each meal on display is brimming with Lancaster County cooking at its finest. Dive into the Dutch heritage of Lititz and indulge in home fries, cornmeal mush, scrapple, rotisserie chicken, BBQ ribs, and more.

[Related: Amish Restaurants in Lancaster PA]

Dosie Dough Bakery | 45 S Broad St, Lititz

Dosie Dough Bakery is part coffee shop, part bakery and part cafe! The ingredients are fresh and the menu is all homemade. You’ll feel right at home in this cozy eclected setting. Make sure you try their European-style breads, or if you prefer, the Bagels are to die for. Be sure to try the Roasted Veggie Wrap which is as healthy as it is delicious.

Tied House | 27-31 E Main St, Lititz

Tied House is an offshoot of St. Boniface Brewing Company in Ephrata. The restaurant's name is derived from the British term, where a “tied house” is a “pub that is owned by a particular beer company and only sells that company’s products.” This place offers a unique libation-focused dining experience: hip space, fantastic drinks and imaginative food, all served up by friendly servers & bartenders. Try the House Made Hot Pastrami Sandwich for a real treat!

Appalachian Brewing Company | 55 N Water St, Lititz

Appalachian Brewing Company is a local chain with six locations in Central Pennsylvania. Their Lititz location is just a block off Main Street in a cool renovated warehouse building. In addition to brewing up their own collection of craft beers, they also make unique locally crafted sodas as well. The menu spans the scope of typical pub food, all freshly prepared and absolutely delicious. We highly recommend the Mile High Meatloaf, but if you're looking for something on the lighter side, the Rockfish Tacos are delish!

Blackworth Live Fire Grill | 48 N Broad St, Lititz

Blackworth is a hip restaurant located on the first floor of the Wilbur Hotel in downtown Lititz. They serve a seasonal menu that changes four times a year. The vibe here is "rustic but refined". Our current favorite menu item is the Mangalista Pork Steak (considered the "Kobe Beef of Pork") with Rosemary French Fries and Roasted Brussels Sprouts.

Rooster Street Butcher | 11 S Cedar St, Lititz

Rooster Street Butcher has three locations in the Lancaster PA area. The Lititz restaurant & bar produces quality and healthy meat products that locals LOVE. They have incredibly high standards for the animals they butcher and the ingredients that go into everything they make. Therefore you won't find any chemicals, fillers, binders, or JUNK in anything they serve! We suggest starting with the Crispy Cauliflower & then have the Rooster Sandwich.

Per Diem | 50 Rock Lititz Blvd, Lititz

Per Diem is located in the Rock Lititz Hotel just outside of downtown Lititz. They cook up fresh ingredients sourced from regional farms, foragers & producers. Rock Lititz is a unique space is where roadies and rock stars themselves stay when they're working on staging their big concert tours. So look around the dining room while you're there, you could spot someone famous!

The White Swan | 1264 E Newport Rd, Lititz

The White Swan Restaurant is located in the oldest building in Rothsville, built in 1790! It's a local pub/restaurant with traditional American cuisine served up for lunch on weekends and dinner 5 days a week (closed Monday and Tuesday). You can choose to dine at the custom wrap-around bar, dining room or in the outdoor patio.

Brunnerville Hotel | 1301 Front St, Lititz

If you're a fan of hidden gems, then you should definitely check out the Brunnerville Hotel! They're open 7 days a week for dinner and serve lunch on weekends (Friday - Sunday). Set in an unassuming building on a backroad in Lititz, the staff serves guests unexpectedly delicious food. Sit at the bar with the locals, choose a table in the dining room, or when the weather cooperates they have a terrific patio as well. Check the Brunnerville Hotel facebook page for Specials. Our last time there it was TO DIE FOR Lobster Rolls!!

Enjoy a Relaxing Weekend Getaway at the Historic Smithton Inn

A Blue hand-sewn Amish quilt sits atop this queen sized, hand-carved bed. After spending a fun night at one of the best Lititz restaurants, come back to your room at The Historic Smithton Inn! The Blue Bird Room is ideal for a cozy weekend getaway where you can enjoy a luxurious locally-crafted queen bed as well as a private bathroom with a tub and shower. Relax by the fireplace with our special cheese platter and a glass of wine and start the next day with our delicious homemade breakfast

Book your stay today and have a wonderful experience at The Historic Smithton Inn!

We hope you enjoy our collection of the 9 Best Restaurants in Lititz.

If you liked this Blog, you might enjoy checking out these next:

Like what you see? Save any of these pins (or possibly all of them) to your travel planning board(s). This will give you an easy way to find your way back here! You can check out our other blog posts for more ideas and pins!