5 of the Best Amish Restaurants in Lancaster, PA

Amish restaurants in Lancaster, PA

Lancaster County, where our beautiful inn is located, has the largest Amish settlement in the world. Those roots still run deep in our community, giving our area a calmer, slower feel than bustling cities. Nowhere is this more evident than the selection of incredible Amish restaurants in Lancaster, PA. These great eateries are serving up hearty food that’ll stick to your ribs. These unique restaurants in Lancaster, PA are worth a visit!

Looking for more suggestions for niche places to eat, like Amish restaurants in Lancaster, PA? Download our free Vacation Guide!  We’ve listed our favorite eateries, as well as our favorite museums, hiking spots, and golf courses in Lancaster County.

Try These Amazing Amish Restaurants in Lancaster, PA!

Good ‘N Plenty

For a taste of Pennsylvania Amish Country, visit the Good ‘N Plenty restaurant in Smoketown, PA. This restaurant has been serving up world-famous buckets of fried chicken, buttered noodles, shoofly pie, and homemade ice cream since 1969! Choose your dinner from the menu or try the popular family-style dining, which serves platters of hearty food to be passed around by the guests. Make sure to visit the gift shop and bakery for something to take home with you.

Plain & Fancy

A visit to The Plain & Fancy Farm means more than just a great meal. It’s an essential part of the Amish experience in Lancaster, PA! At this venue, you can choose from a menu of farm-to-table Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine or tasty American BBQ and locally hand-crafted beer. Enjoy the on-premise attractions, like the Amish buggy rides, farmland tour, and Amish Country Homestead. There’s plenty to see, do, and eat at The Plain & Fancy Farm!


A favorite of many New Holland residents, Yoder’s Country Market features famous hot buffets. Make sure to try the corn fritters or the Pennsylvania Dutch potato filling as well as the classic “broasted” chicken. There is plenty of delicious food from which to choose! If you happen to be visiting on your birthday, make sure to stop by to enjoy a free birthday buffet meal. Now that’s hospitality!


Dienner’s Country Restaurant in Ronks, PA, is serving up fantastic food made with love. Established in 1993, this is a family-owned business that features the foods the owners enjoyed while growing up Amish. Choose an item off the dinner menu, enjoy the all-you-can-eat buffet, or try the daily special. No matter which you decide, you’re sure to enjoy your meal.

Oregon Dairy Country Restaurant & Buffet

You’ll get more than a great meal at Oregon Dairy Country Restaurant & Buffet. You’ll also be able to shop The Market at Oregon Dairy, which carries fresh local produce, high-quality meat and seafood, and homemade baked goods. At the restaurant, you’ll find authentic Amish fare with a modern twist, like Kauffman’s apple butter BBQ chicken or macaroni and cheese with stewed tomatoes. They also have a gluten-free menu with a wide selection. Try the turkey cranberry grill, which features a grilled turkey breast covered in melted cheddar cheese and cranberry relish.

Return to Historic Smithton Inn After Your Amish Feast

Once you’ve indulged in the delicious fare at these great Amish restaurants in Lancaster, PA, return to the Historic Smithton Inn for a great night’s sleep. Our bed and breakfast, located in the heart of Pennsylvania Dutch Country, is the perfect hub for visitors who wish to explore the many local attractions. Our rooms have the rustic feel of an authentic Amish home, with antique and handcrafted furnishings, but with modern amenities, like our charging station for electric vehicles! Browse our guest rooms and book your stay today! We look forward to having you.